1031 exchange in Carmel and Pebble Beach: rentals, second homes and timing
Many Carmel, Carmel-by-the-Sea and Pebble Beach homes are second homes or rentals, and that is when 1031 questions come up at listing time. Here is how the IRS and California describe like-kind exchanges, what the vacation-home safe harbor requires, and why timing is tight in a small market. This is general information, not tax advice.
By Jonathan Balog, Broker Associate, Compass · Carmel-by-the-Sea · Facts checked Nov 18, 2026
The short version: A 1031 exchange can defer gain when you exchange real property held for business or investment for other like-kind real property. A home used only as a personal residence does not qualify. For a vacation home, IRS Revenue Procedure 2008-16 gives a safe harbor: own it for 24 months before the exchange and, in each of those two years, rent it at a fair rental for 14 days or more while keeping personal use to the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days rented. In a deferred exchange you must identify replacement property within 45 days and receive it within 180 days. California exempts qualifying exchanges from its 3 1/3% withholding but still withholds if you receive more than $1,500 in cash or other property. Talk to your tax advisor and a qualified intermediary before you list.
Days to identify
Replacement property, in writing.
Days to close
Or your tax return due date, if earlier.
Months
Safe harbor ownership period for a dwelling.
CA threshold
Cash or other property above this triggers withholding.
What a 1031 exchange is, per the IRS
The short version of the rules every seller should know before talking to an advisor.
Business or investment property only
The IRS describes a like-kind exchange as exchanging real property used for business or held as an investment solely for other business or investment property of the same type.
Real property only
Since the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, section 1031 applies only to exchanges of real property, not personal or intangible property. Property held primarily for sale does not qualify.
Like-kind is broad
Real properties are generally like-kind regardless of whether they are improved or unimproved. U.S. real property is not like-kind to property outside the United States.
Cash out is taxable
If you also receive money or other property, you recognize gain up to that amount. Exchanges are reported on Form 8824.
Second homes and the vacation-home safe harbor
Where most Carmel and Pebble Beach questions land.
A personal residence does not qualify
Revenue Procedure 2008-16 cites earlier rulings and court cases holding that a home used only for personal purposes is not held for investment, even if you expect it to appreciate.
The safe harbor for the home you sell
The IRS will not challenge a dwelling unit as investment property if you owned it for at least 24 months immediately before the exchange and, in each of the two 12-month periods, rented it at a fair rental for 14 days or more and kept personal use to the greater of 14 days or 10% of the days rented.
The same test for the home you buy
A replacement dwelling must meet the same standards for the 24 months after the exchange. If it does not, the procedure says to amend the return and not report an exchange.
Only one piece of the puzzle
The safe harbor answers only the “held for investment” question. Every other 1031 requirement still applies. Outside the safe harbor, it depends on your facts.
The 45-day and 180-day clocks
Why timing is the hard part in a small market.
Identify in 45 days
In a deferred exchange, the replacement property must be identified in writing within 45 days after you transfer the property you give up, per the Form 8824 instructions.
Close in 180 days
You must receive the replacement property within 180 days, or by the due date of your tax return (including extensions) for that year, whichever is earlier.
A small market
Over November 2025 to October 2026, 76 single-family homes sold in Carmel-by-the-Sea, 69 across the Carmel-area neighborhoods and 88 in Pebble Beach. If you plan to buy your replacement here, start looking before you list.
A qualified intermediary
Sellers usually use a qualified intermediary to hold the proceeds in a deferred exchange. Choose one with your advisor before escrow closes on the sale.
California rules on top of the federal ones
Two Franchise Tax Board items that come up at escrow.
Withholding
California generally withholds 3 1/3% of the sales price at escrow. A sale that is part of a qualifying like-kind exchange is exempt, but escrow must withhold if you receive more than $1,500 of money or other property, and the intermediary must withhold if the exchange does not qualify.
Replacement outside California
If you exchange California property for property in another state, the FTB requires Form 3840 for the year of the exchange and each year after, until the deferred gain is recognized.
Form 593
Escrow will ask you to complete Form 593 and choose an exemption box before closing. Ask your advisor which applies.
FTB: 2026 Form 593 instructions ↗FTB Publication 1016 ↗FTB: real estate withholding ↗
Local factors that affect a 1031 plan here
Rental history is what matters for the safe harbor, and local rental rules shape it.
Short-term rental rules
Rules differ between Carmel-by-the-Sea and the County, and in Pebble Beach the property owners’ association says Pebble Beach Company is not issuing consent for vacation rentals while the County finishes its rules. See Carmel-by-the-Sea rental rules and Pebble Beach short-term rentals.
Monthly and long-term rentals
Many owners rent for 30 days or more instead. See long-term rentals and taxes and renting out your home.
If it is not an exchange
A sale of a second home is usually taxable. My selling a second home in Carmel and Pebble Beach guide covers capital gains, California withholding and FIRPTA.
A planning checklist for a 1031 sale
Most of this needs to happen before the listing goes live.
1. Talk to your tax advisor
Confirm whether the home qualifies, and whether the safe harbor or your facts support investment use. Gather rental records and personal-use days for the last two years.
2. Line up an intermediary
Pick a qualified intermediary with your advisor well before the sale closes.
3. Shop before you sell
With 45 days to identify, start looking at replacement property early. I can watch for homes before they hit the market.
4. Price it right
A clean, well-priced sale keeps your timeline intact. Start with a home valuation.
5. Tell escrow early
Escrow needs to know it is an exchange for Form 593 and for the intermediary.
Related guides
Other guides on this site that pair with this one.
- Buying a home in Carmel
- Buying a home in Carmel-by-the-Sea
- Buying a home in Pebble Beach
- Best real estate agent in Carmel
- Choosing an agent in Carmel-by-the-Sea
- Best real estate agent in Pebble Beach
- Selling a second home
- Carmel-by-the-Sea second homes
- Selling a home in Carmel
- Selling a Pebble Beach home
- Home valuation
- Closing costs in Carmel and Pebble Beach
- What is my Carmel-by-the-Sea home worth?
Planning a 1031 sale or purchase? Let’s get the timing right.
I work with your tax advisor and intermediary on the real estate side: pricing the sale, lining up replacement options early and keeping escrow on schedule.
Selling a second homeHome valuationHow I work with sellers
Questions about a 1031 exchange?
Call or text 831-747-0310, or book a 30-minute call. I am a Broker Associate with Compass, DRE 01980970.
Before you rely on this
- This is general information, not tax or legal advice. Whether your exchange qualifies depends on your facts; talk to a tax advisor and a qualified intermediary.
- Federal rules are from the IRS (like-kind exchange tips, Form 8824 instructions and Revenue Procedure 2008-16); California rules are from the Franchise Tax Board, checked Nov 18, 2026.
- I am a real estate broker, not a tax advisor.
1031 exchange: quick questions
Can I do a 1031 exchange on a vacation home in Carmel or Pebble Beach?
Possibly. A home used only personally does not qualify. IRS Revenue Procedure 2008-16 gives a safe harbor if you owned it 24 months before the exchange and, in each of those years, rented it at a fair rental for 14 days or more with limited personal use. Ask your tax advisor.
How long do I have to find a replacement property?
In a deferred exchange, you must identify it in writing within 45 days after transferring the property you sell, and receive it within 180 days or by your tax return due date, if earlier.
Does California withhold tax on a 1031 exchange?
A qualifying like-kind exchange is exempt from California’s real estate withholding, but escrow must withhold if you receive more than $1,500 in money or other property.
Can I exchange a Carmel rental for property in another state?
Federally, U.S. real property is generally like-kind to other U.S. real property. California then requires Form 3840 each year until the deferred gain is recognized.
Can I exchange my main home?
A home used solely as a personal residence does not qualify for section 1031. The main-home exclusion is a separate rule; ask your tax advisor.
What if I take some cash out?
Cash or other non-like-kind property you receive is taxable up to the amount of your gain.
Is this tax advice?
No. It is general information from IRS and FTB sources. Your tax advisor should confirm what applies to you.
Get The Balog Report.
Peninsula market notes, Carmel-by-the-Sea and Pebble Beach listings worth a look, and the practical local tips I share with clients between showings.
Want a sample? Read the latest issue. Planning a move? Get in touch.
The next issue of The Balog Report will land in your inbox. Can’t wait? Read the latest issue.


