Selling a second home in Carmel or Pebble Beach: the tax and withholding rules to plan for
If your Carmel-by-the-Sea, Carmel or Pebble Beach home is a second home, and especially if you live out of state, selling it works differently from selling a main home: the home sale exclusion usually does not apply, California may hold back part of the price at closing, and foreign owners face federal withholding too. Here is what the IRS and the California Franchise Tax Board say, so you can plan before you list.
By Jonathan Balog, Broker Associate, Compass · Carmel-by-the-Sea · Facts checked Nov 12, 2026
The short version: The $250,000 / $500,000 home sale exclusion is for a main home, so a vacation or second home usually does not get it. California requires withholding on most sales of California real estate: 3 1/3% of the total sales price, unless you certify an exemption or choose the alternative calculation on Form 593 before escrow closes. California taxes capital gains as ordinary income, and it taxes gains on California real property no matter where the seller lives. If the seller is a foreign person, the buyer generally must also withhold 15% under FIRPTA. Talk to your tax advisor early, because some of these choices have to be made before closing.
CA withholding
Of the total sales price, unless an exemption or the alternative method applies.
FIRPTA
Of the amount realized, when the seller is a foreign person.
Years
Ownership and use needed for the main home exclusion.
Before closing
Give it to escrow before the transaction closes.
Why a second home is taxed differently
The home sale exclusion is built for the home you live in.
The main home exclusion
The IRS lets you exclude up to $250,000 of gain from the sale of your main home, or $500,000 on a joint return, if you owned it and lived in it for at least two of the five years before the sale.
Second and vacation homes
The Franchise Tax Board lists rental property, vacation homes and second homes as properties that generally do not count as a principal residence. IRS Publication 523 adds that using a home as a second home or rental after 2008 can reduce the exclusion even if you later live there.
Federal rates
Long-term gains are taxed at 0%, 15% or 20% depending on income, and the part of a gain that comes from depreciation on real property (unrecaptured section 1250 gain) is taxed at up to 25%, per IRS Topic 409.
California rates
California does not have a lower rate for capital gains. The Franchise Tax Board says all capital gains are taxed as ordinary income.
If it was ever rented
If you claimed depreciation, IRS Publication 523 says the part of the gain equal to depreciation after May 6, 1997 cannot be excluded, even when some of the gain otherwise qualifies.
IRS Topic 701, sale of your home ↗IRS Publication 523 ↗IRS Topic 409, capital gains ↗FTB: capital gains ↗
California real estate withholding and Form 593
The rule that surprises most second-home sellers at closing.
The default
Unless an exemption applies, California law requires withholding when an individual, business, trust or estate sells California real property. The standard amount is 3 1/3% of the total sales price, held back in escrow and sent to the Franchise Tax Board.
Full exemptions
You may owe no withholding if the home was your principal residence under the two-of-five-years test, if you last used it as your principal residence, if the sale produces a loss or zero gain, or in certain involuntary conversions. Sales of $100,000 or less are not subject to withholding.
The alternative calculation
Instead of 3 1/3% of the price, a seller can elect to have withholding figured on the estimated gain at the maximum rate. For an individual, the 2026 Form 593 uses 12.3% of the gain. A seller with a large price but a modest gain may want to compare both methods with a tax advisor.
Timing matters
Form 593 has to reach the escrow person before the close of the transaction to prevent or reduce withholding. After closing, money already withheld can be recovered only as a credit on your California tax return.
Sign carefully
The Franchise Tax Board says the penalty for knowingly signing a false exemption certificate is the greater of $1,000 or 20% of the required withholding. Escrow officers are not allowed to give tax advice on which method to choose.
FTB: real estate withholding ↗FTB Publication 1016 ↗2026 Form 593 instructions ↗
If you live outside California
Where you live does not change where the home is.
California still taxes the gain
The Franchise Tax Board’s guide for nonresidents says California taxes real property based on where the property is located. A gain on a Carmel-by-the-Sea or Pebble Beach home is California-source income even if you live in another state.
Withholding applies the same way
The 3 1/3% withholding and the Form 593 exemptions apply to out-of-state sellers too. The withholding is credited when you file your California return.
Your home state
Your home state may also tax the gain and may offer a credit for tax paid to California. That depends on your state, so ask your tax advisor.
Foreign owners and FIRPTA
A separate federal withholding on top of California’s.
15% of the amount realized
Under FIRPTA, a buyer purchasing U.S. real property from a foreign person generally must withhold 15% of the amount realized. In most cases the buyer is the withholding agent, and a buyer who fails to withhold may be held liable for the tax.
The residence exception
No FIRPTA withholding is generally required if the buyer will use the home as a residence and the price is not more than $300,000, under conditions the IRS lists. Above that price, the 15% rule applies unless another exception or a withholding certificate does.
Mixed ownership
If one spouse is a U.S. person and the other is foreign, the IRS says the amount realized is allocated by contribution, with spouses treated as contributing 50% each, and the buyer withholds on the foreign owner’s share.
California is separate
The Franchise Tax Board says foreign sellers follow the same California withholding rules as domestic sellers, so both federal and state withholding can apply to the same sale.
If the home was a rental or investment
A like-kind exchange can defer gain, but only for qualifying property. I walk through the federal clocks, California withholding and local timing in 1031 exchange in Carmel and Pebble Beach.
What qualifies
The IRS describes a like-kind exchange as an exchange of real property used for business or held as an investment for other business or investment real property. Whether a home you also used personally qualifies is a question for your tax advisor.
Cash out is taxable
If you receive money or other property in the exchange, you recognize gain up to that amount. U.S. real property is not like-kind to property outside the United States. Exchanges are reported on Form 8824.
California withholding
A sale that is part of a qualifying 1031 exchange can be exempt from California withholding, but withholding applies if you receive more than $1,500 of cash or other property, and the intermediary must withhold if the exchange fails.
Replacement out of state
The Franchise Tax Board requires anyone who exchanges California real property for like-kind property outside California to file form FTB 3840 with their California return.
Local items that come with any sale here
Not tax law, but they belong on the same checklist.
Transfer tax
Monterey County’s documentary transfer tax is $0.55 per $500 of value. Who pays it is negotiated in the contract.
Water fixtures
The Monterey Peninsula Water Management District has water-efficiency requirements tied to a change of ownership. Check them early so they do not hold up escrow.
Sewer lateral
In much of the Carmel area, the Carmel Area Wastewater District has a sewer lateral rule tied to a sale. See my sewer lateral inspection guide.
Rentals and buyers
If the home has been a vacation rental, buyers will ask about permits. Rules differ: see Carmel-by-the-Sea rental rules and Pebble Beach short-term rentals.
A planning checklist for second-home sellers
Most of this is easier months before you list than days before closing.
1. Gather your basis records
Find your purchase closing statement and records of improvements. Your gain depends on your adjusted basis, and the alternative withholding method uses it.
2. Pull depreciation history
If the home was ever rented, get the depreciation you claimed from your past returns.
3. Ask your tax advisor which Form 593 box fits
Principal residence, last used as principal residence, loss, 1031, or the alternative calculation. Decide before escrow opens.
4. Foreign owners: start early
If any owner is a foreign person, talk to your advisor about FIRPTA and whether to apply for a withholding certificate.
5. Price it with real comps
A good net starts with the right price. My home valuation and monthly stats for Carmel-by-the-Sea, Carmel and Pebble Beach show what is selling now.
Related guides
Other guides on this site that pair with this one.
- Selling a home in Carmel-by-the-Sea
- Selling a home in Carmel
- Selling a Pebble Beach home
- Home selling tips
- Buying a second home in Carmel-by-the-Sea
- Inherited homes in Carmel and Pebble Beach
- Carmel and Pebble Beach property taxes
- Best real estate agent in Pebble Beach
- Best real estate agent in Carmel
- Choosing an agent in Carmel-by-the-Sea
Selling from out of town? I can run it locally.
If you are managing the sale from somewhere else, I handle the local side: pricing, preparing the house, vendors, showings and the escrow checklist, and I bring your tax advisor and escrow officer in early so Form 593 and any FIRPTA questions are settled before closing, not at the last minute.
I represented the buyers of San Antonio 2 SW of 10th ($7M) and Lincoln 3 NE of 5th ($4.4M), and both sides of Torres 2 SE of 10th ($5.54M). I represented the buyer of 1424 Oleada Road in Pebble Beach in 2025.
Carmel-by-the-Sea homesCarmel homesPebble Beach homes
Thinking about selling a second home?
Call or text 831-747-0310, or book a 30-minute call. I am a Broker Associate with Compass, DRE 01980970.
Before you rely on this
- This page is general information, not tax or legal advice. Tax results depend on your facts. Work with a CPA or tax attorney before you list.
- Federal rules are from IRS Topic 701, Topic 409, Publication 523 and the IRS FIRPTA pages. California rules are from FTB Publication 1016 (revised 02/2026), the 2026 Form 593 instructions, the FTB capital gains page and FTB Publication 1100, all read Nov 12, 2026. Rates and forms change each year.
- The transfer tax figure is from Monterey County Code 5.32.
Selling a second home: quick questions
Do I get the $250,000 or $500,000 exclusion when I sell a second home?
Usually not. The exclusion is for a main home you owned and lived in for at least two of the five years before the sale. The Franchise Tax Board lists vacation homes and second homes as properties that generally do not count as a principal residence.
How much does California withhold when I sell?
The standard amount is 3 1/3% of the total sales price. A seller can instead elect the alternative calculation, which applies the maximum tax rate to the estimated gain (12.3% for an individual on the 2026 Form 593), or certify a full exemption on Form 593.
When do I have to turn in Form 593?
Before the close of escrow. If escrow does not have a completed and signed Form 593 showing an exemption before closing, withholding is required, and money withheld can only be recovered as a credit on your California return.
I live in another state. Does California still tax the gain?
Yes. The Franchise Tax Board says California taxes real property based on where the property is located, so a gain on a home here is California-source income.
What is FIRPTA withholding?
When a foreign person sells U.S. real property, the buyer generally must withhold 15% of the amount realized and send it to the IRS. There are exceptions, including a home bought as the buyer’s residence for $300,000 or less.
Is capital gain taxed at a lower rate in California?
No. California does not have a lower rate for capital gains. All capital gains are taxed as ordinary income.
Can I do a 1031 exchange on a vacation home?
A 1031 exchange is for real property used for business or held as an investment. Whether a home you also used personally qualifies depends on your facts, so ask your tax advisor before you list.
Get The Balog Report.
Peninsula market notes, Carmel-by-the-Sea and Pebble Beach listings worth a look, and the practical local tips I share with clients between showings.
Want a sample? Read the latest issue. Planning a move? Get in touch.
The next issue of The Balog Report will land in your inbox. Can’t wait? Read the latest issue.


