Market data · Carmel Highlands · Updated November 2026

Most expensive homes sold in Carmel Highlands

The 25 highest MLS sales in Carmel Highlands, from all years in Jonathan's Nov 18, 2026 export, plus one recorded off-market sale that is not in the MLS table. These are market sales, not a list of his transactions.

The short version: The highest MLS sale in this export is 171 Spindrift Rd, which closed at $26,000,000 on Mar 30, 2022. A separate recorded off-market sale at 105 Highway 1 is shown on the county record at $40,000,000 on July 12, 2022; news reports identified that property as the D.L. James House and attributed the purchase to Brad Pitt. The MLS list has 25 sales and runs down to $7,825,000.

$26,000,000

Highest MLS sale

171 Spindrift Rd, closed Mar 30, 2022.

$40,000,000

Recorded off-market sale

105 Highway 1, July 12, 2022, not in the MLS table.

25

MLS sales on this list

Top 25 by sale price, all years.

$7,825,000

25th on the MLS list

The cutoff in this export.

How to read this

How this Carmel Highlands list was built

MLS sales in one table, and one recorded off-market sale in its own callout.

These lists cover MLS sales only. Some of the area's biggest sales happen off market and never appear in the MLS. The tables below are the top 25 sales by sale price in each area, from all years in Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026, and they are not Jonathan Balog's personal sales. He did not necessarily represent the buyer or the seller on any of them.

Off-market

A recorded off-market sale at 105 Highway 1

This sale is not a row in the MLS table below.

A recorded off-market sale, not in the MLS tables

The lists on this page cover only sales that were entered in the MLS. Some of the area's biggest sales happen off market and never show up there.

One example is 105 Highway 1 in Carmel Highlands, the property known as the D.L. James House. A Monterey County property record for APN 241-111-001-000 shows a sale price of $40,000,000 and a sale date of Jul 12, 2022, on a 109,336 square-foot lot (about 2.51 acres). The sale was recorded on Jul 18, 2022.

The Wall Street Journal reported on July 25, 2022, that Brad Pitt paid $40 million for the circa-1918 D.L. James House, a bluff-top home in the Carmel Highlands, according to public records and people familiar with the deal. The Carmel Pine Cone (July 29, 2022), Architectural Digest and Vanity Fair also reported the $40 million figure and the Pitt attribution, citing the Journal. The Pine Cone wrote that county records confirm the sale but do not name Pitt, and that the property includes another home just north of the historic house. Vanity Fair, citing the Journal, wrote that the house was never publicly listed and sold off market, and that local agents described it at the time as the most expensive home ever sold in the Carmel area.

The county record lists a year built of 1940 and a building size of 695 square feet. That does not match the published descriptions of the historic house, which news outlets described as designed in 1918 by Charles Sumner Greene and as about 3,000 square feet. Because those figures disagree, this page uses the record for the price and the date, and treats the year built and square footage as unsettled.

This is market information. It is not a sale Jonathan Balog was involved in.

The 25 MLS sales

The 25 highest MLS sales in Carmel Highlands

Ranked by sale price. A house that sold more than once can appear more than once.

#AddressSale priceClose dateSq ftPrice/sq ftYear builtDOM
1171 Spindrift Rd$26,000,000Mar 30, 20224,335$5,998192228
2165 Spindrift Rd$16,100,000Jul 22, 20206,481$2,4842019160
3166 Spindrift Rd$16,000,000May 3, 20216,432$2,4881997248
430680 Aurora del Mar$14,750,000Jun 25, 20253,851$3,8301973319
5157 Spindrift Rd$14,435,135Sep 4, 201812,000$1,2031983203
6182 Van Ess Way$13,000,000Apr 30, 20044,300$3,023not listed41
7162 Spindrift Rd$12,740,000Sep 9, 20222,781$4,58119564
872 Fern Canyon Rd$11,500,000Sep 11, 202612,175$9451921488
9254 Highway 1$11,500,000Oct 3, 20255,836$1,9711994138
10182 Van Ess Way$11,500,000Jan 31, 20074,300$2,674not listed119
11169 Spindrift Rd$10,500,000Aug 15, 20124,236$2,4791996181
12237 Highway 1$10,500,000Jul 18, 20006,526$1,609not listed35
13108 Yankee Point Dr$10,000,000Jan 6, 20223,575$2,79719653
14104 Yankee Point Dr$9,900,000Jul 27, 20263,108$3,1852007143
15230 Highway 1$9,600,000Nov 4, 20216,670$1,43920140
1614 Spindrift Rd$9,250,000Jul 11, 20124,980$1,857200121
1730680 Aurora del Mar$8,995,000Sep 4, 20073,917$2,296not listed247
1830680 Aurora del Mar$8,700,000Mar 13, 20153,851$2,2591973478
19Spindrift Rd$8,600,000Mar 15, 20115,686$1,5121921105
2030530 Aurora del Mar$8,475,000Nov 14, 20252,906$2,9161983156
21162 Spindrift Rd$8,475,000Sep 27, 20182,781$3,0471956245
2230860 Aurora del Mar$8,088,178Apr 16, 20214,223$1,9152004148
23243 Highway 1$8,071,480Jun 27, 20222,667$3,0262017596
24176 Spindrift Rd$8,000,000Aug 2, 20224,730$1,691192086
2530500 Aurora del Mar$7,825,000Dec 8, 20174,477$1,7481988156

Top 25 MLS sales in Carmel Highlands by sale price, all years, from Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026. The recorded $40,000,000 sale at 105 Highway 1 is not in this table. Tap a column name to sort. On a phone, each sale stacks as a card. Addresses link to Google Maps. Source: Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026. MLS sales only.

Working with me

Looking at Carmel Highlands? Let’s talk it through.

I work with buyers and sellers in Carmel Highlands, and I have many significant Highlands sales. This list is market data, not a list of those sales.

Questions about a high-end sale or purchase?

Call or text 831-747-0310, or book a 30-minute call. I am a Broker Associate with Compass, DRE 01980970.

Before you rely on this

  • The table is MLS sales only, from Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026. Some of the area's biggest sales happen off market and never appear in the MLS.
  • These are market sales, not a list of sales Jonathan Balog represented. He has many significant Carmel Highlands sales, but this page does not list them.
  • The $40,000,000 sale is from a Monterey County property record (APN 241-111-001-000, sale date July 12, 2022). News outlets attributed that sale to Brad Pitt and identified the property as the D.L. James House. The record and the news coverage disagree on year built and building size.
  • Price per square foot is computed from the sale price and the square footage in the export, rounded to the nearest dollar.

Carmel Highlands sales: quick questions

What is the most expensive MLS sale in Carmel Highlands?

In this MLS export, 171 Spindrift Rd closed at $26,000,000 on Mar 30, 2022. That is an MLS sale only.

What about the D.L. James House?

A Monterey County property record shows $40,000,000 on July 12, 2022, at 105 Highway 1 in Carmel Highlands. News reports, led by the Wall Street Journal, identified the property as the D.L. James House and attributed the purchase to Brad Pitt. It is not in the MLS table.

Is that $40 million sale in the MLS?

No. It is featured as a recorded off-market sale. The MLS table starts at $26,000,000.

Did Jonathan Balog represent any of these sales?

This page does not say that, and you should not assume it. These are market sales. He has many significant Carmel Highlands sales, but they are not listed here.

Do you include other off-market sales?

No. Only this one recorded sale is called out, because the county record and published news coverage are in hand. Other off-market sales may have happened and would not appear in the table.

Why do some addresses appear more than once?

30680 Aurora Del Mar, 182 Van Ess Way and 162 Spindrift Rd each have more than one sale in the top 25. Each sale is kept as its own row.

Where does this data come from?

Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026 for the MLS table, and a Monterey County property record reviewed Nov 18, 2026, plus the cited news articles, for the off-market callout.

Updated November 2026 · Facts checked Nov 18, 2026 against Jonathan's MLS export, Nov 18, 2026
Be in the loop

Get The Balog Report.

Peninsula market notes, Carmel-by-the-Sea and Pebble Beach listings worth a look, and the practical local tips I share with clients between showings.

Want a sample? Read the latest issue. Planning a move? Get in touch.

Please enter a valid email.

Unsubscribe anytime.

You’re in. Thank you!
The next issue of The Balog Report will land in your inbox. Can’t wait? Read the latest issue.
Jonathan Balog, Broker Associate | Compass | DRE# 01980970
6th Ave. 2 SW of San Carlos St., Carmel-by-the-Sea, CA 93921